Cooked books

Newsday Editorial
Friday, May 13 2016 –

THE BOOKS have been cooked.

TheftRecent disclosures to Parliament have led us to conclude that the State’s financial accounting is seriously flawed. The books have been rendered defective through suspect accounting practices, gaps in oversight of revenue, and the use of tactics that have the effect of masking shortfalls. The result? A distorted picture. A Budget statement every year, yet no true accountability.

According to Auditor General Majeed Ali, the State has been placing its $33 billion overdraft under assets in its books. “Generally accepted accounting principles require that an overdraft of this nature be shown as a liability,” says Ali in his Report on the Public Accounts of Trinidad and Tobago for the year ended September 2015. The document was tabled in Parliament last month. While the overdraft dates back to 2003, there is no doubt that the People’s Partnership (PP) administration at the very least failed to address this anomaly. Would shifting $33 billion not have a substantial effect on the overall balance sheet? There have also been subtle moves at State enterprises. A Joint Select Committee of Parliament on Tuesday heard of the National Gas Company (NGC) paying out a massive $6.8 billion dividend to its shareholder — the State — even as profits dropped to $605 million.

“Extraordinary,” said Independent Senator David Small. The sum came out of retained earnings.

Perhaps the State was able to draw upon revenues from an initial public offering involving the NGC, but did that comprise the full extent of the $6.8 billion? Whatever the case, the use of IPOs as a means of ostensibly bolstering revenue in the annual accounts has hidden implications.

IPOs represent the sale of State assets.

They turn long-term resources into short-term gains. While private ownership is encouraged, the State’s leverage is diminished over time. Its ability to use assets to seek financing is reduced. The books might appear more flush, but closer and closer we inch towards agencies like the International Monetary Fund.

Add to this the lax oversight of regulatory bodies and the picture is one of downright subterfuge. On Wednesday, Ministry of Energy officials sheepishly laid bare a litany of problems. This country has depended on the petrochemical industry for decades to fund everything we’ve got. Yet you would not be able to tell this based on what is going on at the ministry.

Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee heard that: 1) the ministry relies on measuring valves controlled by oil companies; 2) there are backlogs — going back years — in relation to the lab work needed to assign values; 3) there is a cosy relationship between the ministry and the same companies it is supposed to regulate; and 4) there are major gaps in the training of inspectors who do not sign-off on inspection reports.

At the same time, there are 5) poor remuneration and human resource arrangements (including in relation to pensions and leave) for ministry employees who are supposed to be the regulators; 6) and there are time limits to the oversight of the Auditor General. Despairingly, Housing Minister Randall Mitchell and Caroni Central MP Dr Bhoe Tewarie — the former Minister of Planning — had to point out to the ministry officials that these circumstances raised a disturbing prospect.

“Is it conceivable that the people of Trinidad and Tobago have been cheated?” Mitchell asked, almost rhetorically. With poor checking arrangements, there is no way to tell whether the revenues recorded were really what was due.

And let’s not even talk about $10 billion leaking, unaudited, at WASA, as well as Auditor General reports tabled years late.

All of these matters may well have predated the PP administration.

That does not absolve them. It now falls on the present PNM administration to raise the standard.

Given the global economic situation, we need to know. Otherwise, crapaud smoke we pipe.


2 thoughts on “Cooked books”

  1. Auditors detect $3.1m URP ‘fraud’

    By Gail Alexander
    Friday, May 13, 2016 –

    The former People’s Partnership administration’s URP social programme hired 300 people as “area foremen” because they were the parents of children with cerebral palsy although there was no evidence they were at work, acting Prime Minister Colm Imbert has said.

    “It’s a very strange arrangement, where you had these people being paid every fortnight as area foremen but not associated with any project, working on any gang and with no evidence they were at work,” he added at yesterday’s post-Cabinet media briefing at the Office of the Prime Minister, St Clair.

    He revealed one of the names listed was that of a “famous person”, but admitted Government didn’t know if it was just someone with the same name. The T&T Guardian learned the name is similar to that of a female personality who was involved in PP’s now defunct Life Sport programme.

    The situation was revealed in an audit of government departments, Imbert said.

    “It was a methodology used by the previous government to give these people money on a monthly basis. It makes no sense to give the money for not performing work. There’s a difference between a salary — money paid for services — and a grant, which is given without expectation of work… this shouldn’t have been hidden under URP’s payroll,” he said.

    Saying it was odd, Imbert added that a few names were associated with special schools but others lacked information and in some it was possible the person listed was not the parent of a child.

    Works Minister Fitzgerald Hinds said the arrangement cost $3.1 million annually over August 2011 to very recently. He said it would be determined if there was fraud or a matter to attract a “different intervention.”

    Imbert said the arrangement would be transferred to Social Development for case-by-case scrutiny, to assist those who need help, via disability/public assistance grant, and determine if there had been any duplication on social development listings.

    Contacted yesterday, former PP social development minister Christine Hosein said she met the “area foreman” arrangement when she entered the ministry and it was started under former minister Glenn Ramadharsingh.

    She said it was not meant that the parents had to do work. She said the programme was started since such parents didn’t qualify under the public assistance/disability criteria. She said she had visited homes of some “area foremen and could vouch they were bona fide cases.

    “The PNM doesn’t take time to try to understand any system. They only want to pass off everything the PP did as waste and corrupt,” she added.

    Calls to Ramdharsingh were not immediately answered.


  2. Mamoo Here is what your people are so good at…FRAUD. Can you spin this one Mamoo?

Comments are closed.