Leveraging Incompetence

By Dr. Selwyn R. Cudjoe
October 14, 2010

Dr. Selwyn R. CudjoeI am sure that People’s Partnership took a long time to select the three hundred persons they elected to the various state enterprises, statutory bodies, regional health authorities and key ambassadorial positions. In making her selection, Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar enunciated two broad principles: a determination to make the correct choices and no one could sit on more than one board.

Necessarily, such a determination presented many opportunities and pitfalls: how to get enough persons with sufficient abilities to overseer the bodies that control the running of our society. Some persons interpreted some of the selections as fitting square pegs in wrong holes while others saw some of the appointments as inundating some honorable persons with responsibilities that may be above their heads.

The selection of Everald Snaggs, former commissioner of police, as the chairman of TSTT sticks out. TSTT, a joint venture with Cable and Wireless, is our most profitable state enterprise. Its Board consists of four representatives from Cable and Wireless and four persons appointed by our government. Necessarily, one counts on the chairman and the four local representatives to protect our national interest as they ensure that we are not overwhelmed by the agenda of a multinational player.

Previously, persons with a reasonable distinguished record in business were placed in charge of this company (such as Richard Azar and Victor Mouttet). Chairman Sam Martin declared a profit of $384.3 million dollars for the fiscal year 2008-09, twice the amount the company declared for the previous year. This time around the PP government has opted for a non-business person who may not possess the business and management skills to hold things together. It would be interesting to see whether this enterprise continues to flourish in a similar manner.

The Prime Minister also named eight chairmen and deputy chairmen to the Regional Health Authorities, seven of whom where Indians. No women were included and they could not have applied for the positions. This mean that for all practical purposes the health of the entire community, including Africans, are now placed in the hands of Indian men which leads one to ask if there are no competent Africans or women who are capable of superintending the health of the nation.

There is another fallacy in these appointments; that is, the premise that only doctors are equipped to serve on these boards and are best educated to run these gigantic organizations? Evidence suggests that professionals who are trained in health management, not necessarily medical doctors, are best equipped to run these health facilities which must be run as businesses in this changing health environment. Again, one must leave these judgments to the honorable Prime Minister and her colleagues who undoubtedly know best.

Under the circumstances, it was heartening to hear Errol McLeod, Minister of Labour, support this labor colleague, Ancil Roget, who came out against the appointment of Lindsay Gillette to chair Petrotrin. Roget declared that his union “was going to struggle against everyone on State boards who they believe should not be there.” Although he did not define the criterion of “who should not be there” it is fair to say that his words suggests that competent persons and those concerned about the welfare of the society should be placed at the helm of these Boards.

Roget also made another starling observation when he said, “We are seeing some old UNC snakes [his word] crawling out of their holes. We have a problem with that.” Interestingly enough this statement was followed by an equally damning statement by front line officials of the Congress of the People (COP) who demanded that appointments to these boards reflect Trinidad and Tobago diversity.

Vernon de Lima, deputy chairman of COP was more emphatic. He likens what has happened as “a shame and scandal in the family.” He called for openness and declared that “something has happened over the past few days that is disturbing and challenges the smooth running of the Partnership-there is a rumbling and a tumbling in the atmosphere.” Although COP members had worked hard to elect a PP government he was not sure if they were being treated “with fairness and consideration.”

Such bad treatment hit the COP hard. Hulsie Bhaggan said it best when she declared that her party felt “bruised and fractured from the psychological and emotional trauma.” Needless to say, such trauma to the psyche is not easily healed. Toney, another official of the COP, said that his party felt “bruised and fractured” from such psychological torture and bemoaned COP’s diminishing influence within the Partnership.

Bruised feelings and fractured are one thing. Objective reality is another thing. The fact is that in a small society such as ours numbers matter. In the last election UNC got 22 seats; COP received 5 seats; and TOP received two seats. UNC received 432,026 or about sixty percent of the votes whereas PNM received 40 percent. McLeod of the Movement for Social Justice was placed on a COP ticket only because his party did not have party symbol.

Bottom line: COP does not have as much influence that it thinks it has.

If the selection on Boards are made on a basis of party affiliation (remember Kamla made it clear at the inception of the Partnership that each member of the coalition would keep its political identity) then COP claims are reduced considerable. If PNM-affiliated persons are not considered for appointments and many accomplished persons are afraid to put their names forward then the available talent to serve is diminished. In this case, the nation suffers and the best talent is left out of the loop.

In 1969 Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hill advanced the Peter Principle in which they stated that no matter how gifted an employee may be at the early and middle stages of their careers eventually he reaches a level of incompetence when promoted beyond his ability. In time, several posts tend to be occupied by employees who are unable to carry out their duties. In other words, they reach the level of their incompetence.

T&T is a small society. If forty percent of the best persons are left out of consideration for the posts on various boards; professionals in COP are side lined and no one can serve on more than one board we reasonable expect levels of incompetence on the boards to take us backward into a bureaucratic nightmare.

Only time will provide the truth or falsity of my proposition. I hope I am wrong in my analysis.

9 thoughts on “Leveraging Incompetence”

  1. The professor was on the board of the Central bank..As a literature professor one would assume that he has limited qualifications in financial matters.It is my impression that he served well enough.
    Is it not ironic that he now questions the qualifications of persons appointed to state boards. And true to form he could not help himself; he had to introduce the race factor.
    Where was he when the PNM filled its state enterprises with party hacks?

  2. “This mean that for all practical purposes the health of the entire community, including Africans, are now placed in the hands of Indian men which leads one to ask if there are no competent Africans or women who are capable of superintending the health of the nation.”

    I agree with Cudjoe here the PP could have at least find a PNM negro to put on that board, shame on them. I think that his politically correct, affirmative action view deserve consideration by the PP. They should examine all State Boards and past government employment practices and begin the process of equalisation. That means 40% Indians and 37% Africans in the Public service. I am of the opinion that the Prof have a good thing going and I wish to commend him. I hope that he would continue to advocate for equalisation, too long has the PNM been able to fill State Boards and hire only their “kind”. It is time according to the Prof that the government hire equally that means imbalances must be corrected immediately. Starting with the Central Bank, where (I don’t know according to Sat) it currently looks like the Congo, that should not be. Then Police, Regiment, Coast Guard would be a good place to start. All other State own companies should quickly follow the prof world view which I strongly agree with. Finally his writings are making sense…

  3. TMan. Was that a typo in your last line? Didnt you intend to say ‘party blacks’? LMAO

  4. Cute one,Philip C.Nunez.
    When the PNM was in power they repeatedly stacked all State Boards with party hacks. The Opposition complained endlessly. They Wanted a balance.
    Hopefully, now that they are in power, they will not practise the same narrow partisan politics and only appoint Indians to State Boards.
    In a country like T&T, any government should always be sensitive to the composition of the population.

    1. Should one always imitate success, and not try to re-invent it?

      “Success” here is seen in this “victimisation” of Indians by Black people.

      This well-marketed, well-funded, and high-decibel “victim status” of Indians is becoming an industry unto itself. Trans-national, too and profitable.

      Maybe there’s a lesson there to be observed, remembered and compared, and then having incorporated it, also sell and buy shares on the stock market.

      Except this industry, like the King Cobra, ultimately has a vast appetite for its own.

  5. T-Man with each passing day I am more convince that you are perhaps one of the most disgusting, lying human being on the face of the earth , or just simply dumb, for if you with all your think that your PP government can survive for any considerable length of time by pushing an African purge agenda , you are sadly mistaken. I would not even attempt to address you imbecilic comment about PNM imbalance .
    The only reason the PNM survived for so long, and our Indo , Chinese, Arab, and European,and all other fringe segments of the population supported them , was because both sides interest, were served-in a ‘you scratch my back, and I’ll scratch yours’- always of course, at the expense of black folks, that they actually took for granted , knowing that the latter would never support encroaching enemies – and now we see why.
    Let’s hope for the good of our country, you and your venomous kind are the last of a dying breed, and that the Canadian cross country ,running star of yours ,choose to get as far away from you quickly , before her mind gets equally poisoned.
    What a phony!

    1. Neal said “The only reason the PNM survived for so long, and our Indo , Chinese, Arab, and European,and all other fringe segments of the population supported them”

      Wrong there Nealos my carib drinking friend. The only reason the PNM survive so long in leading the nation is because they “stole” most of the elections. Nealos you know that blue collar workers are better thieves than the bandits with guns.

      Eric fixed the boundaries and went to bed knowing that all the elections during his leadership would be in the PNM camp. So if you examine the voting patterns and support for the PNM in comparisson to the seats an interesting picture will emerge. In POS south for instance they won with 6,000 votes compared to Chaguanas with 18,000. The boundaries and created to always give the PNM a great advantage. It was not fair.

      It was only after Eric passed away and the power structure underwent some changes. The EBC manage to make boundaries more equitable. Even the great Selwyn Ryan acknowledge that Eric “gerrymander” the boundaries to keep the PNM in power.

      Today, with greater media and public scrutiny it is difficult to pull an “Eric” on the nation. Finally elections are no longer being stolen. In addition to all of this Panday did help the successive PNM administration to stay longer than they should have. His autocratic style did not help.

  6. Excuse me, Mr.Moderator, I will get off my civilized, educated man kick to ask Neal,
    What the f*** he is talking about?
    Is it ignorace, insanity or just plain stupidity?

Comments are closed.