Biden/Harris and the Diverse Faces of US Imperialism

By Dr Tye Salandy
November 13, 2020

Dr Tye SalandyI remember when Barack Obama won his first term as US President in 2008. Late that night, I heard a massive noise of joyful screams and applause from the neighbourhood, the moment his victory was confirmed. At that point, I knew we were in for a rough ride. In the immediate aftermath, my colleague at Trinicenter.com wrote an insightful piece titled President Barack Obama: Change…What Change? that was prophetic of Obama’s presidency. Obama was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, yet his two terms showed an appetite for war-making and violence, albeit cloaked beneath polished words, diplomacy and the goodwill of many people excited to see a non-white face leading the White House. Obama, Biden and Hilary Clinton oversaw the illegal invasion of Libya, turning a stable country into a zone of conflict. Critics would describe Obama as being more “Bush than Bush” as covert drone strikes were dramatically increased, some estimate ten times more than what occurred under George Bush Jr. Despite a seemingly tense relationship with the Israeli Prime Minister, he signed a $38 billion military aid package to Israel. Under the fancy rhetoric of “hope” and “yes we can”, mass surveillance programmes expanded internally and externally.

From Bad Cop to Good Cop

Twelve years ago, the world was good copped/bad copped by Obama and Bush/McCain, and the cycle continues, as many in the world again celebrate the election of the “good guy”, Joe Biden, over the “bad guy”, Donald Trump. Trump’s four years of blatant dishonesty, disdain for basic science, shallowness, misogyny, race-baiting, and childish behaviour has given his critics more than enough evidence that he is not a worthy leader. Trump as the supreme bad guy rightly problematizes overt racism while drawing attention away from structural racism and the polite racism pervasive in white liberal circles. Trump with all his problematic behaviour is an unwitting outlet for racial escapism in which racism is recognised in its overt and hostile (Trumpian and Republican) forms but not in its everyday manifestations that have been so central to Euro-American capitalism. Racism is then seen as an evil-person phenomena rather than as a global, national and individual system of rewards and privileges accorded based on closeness to whiteness.

The euphoria around the victory of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris is reminiscent of the Obama victory of 2008. While representation and firsts are important and have their place, we must be careful of empty symbolism (or tokenism). For us in the Caribbean, women leaders and leaders that look like us have not transformed the structures of inequality or the complicity of governments entangled within global capitalism. In one sense, it is easy to see how, in the context of white supremacy and patriarchy, the election of Obama then, and Harris now could make many people feel good. Beyond the shallowness of these symbols, the core structures of unjust American power do not just continue but are reinforced by the notions of merit, hard work and the fulfilment of the American dream.

Democrats and Republicans: Two Sides of the Same Coin

The differences between the Democrats and the Republicans is that the Republicans are relatively crude and straightforward in promoting war, white supremacy and US imperialism as core values while the Democrats are more measured and diplomatic. Democrats speak the language of peace, hope and dialogue, yet, behind this, the internal and global violence of a declining US empire continues unabated. This explains how Trump is globally reviled (understandably so), but Obama is revered by many despite his record of war, intervention, and violence. While Trump was a clear symbol that something was wrong in the White House, Obama and the Democratic tradition of governance took the edge off the empire and lulled Americans and people globally into a state of sleep and complacency.

While the leaders of the Democratic Party extol the virtues of American democracy at home and abroad, the Democratic Party is anything but democratic. In the 2016 Democrat Party primaries, party elites openly rallied around Hilary Clinton. The blatant rigging of internal party processes against relatively more progressive party members is a reminder of the character of the party and why the narratives of change and hope around Joe Biden and Kamala Harris are misplaced. Yet, for those who are still unconvinced, the records of both Biden and Harris are prophetic about what we should expect.

Biden, Kamala and the Illusions of Change

Joe Biden has spent a career in leading roles in American power structures and his legacy is anything but progressive and transformational. In 1994, the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act, also called the Clinton Crime Bill or the Biden Crime Law was passed. Joe Biden was influential in this law that was instrumental in overwhelmingly targeting and incarcerating people of colour. He supported the illegal US invasions of both Afghanistan and Iraq, and the expanded drone assassinations under President Obama. Like Harris, he is a strong supporter of Israel. His public speeches of healing and unity seem a far cry now from back in the civil rights era where he opposed busing and desegregation. (For more on Biden See here: www.leftvoice.org/joe-biden-is-not-a-decent-man)

Kamala Harris’ ascendency to power may seem to be an example of hard work and the shattering of a glass ceiling that hold women back, however, for anyone truly interested in justice her record is not the example on which transformation can be built. During her time as District Attorney and Attorney General, Kamala Harris is credited with a Back on Track programme (aimed at keeping young offenders out of jail), an open justice database (for public access to crime statistics) as well as implicit racial bias training for cops. Yet, while Harris has positioned herself as progressive and a reformer, beyond a few initiatives, her record is one of upholding the status quo. Harris pioneered a truancy bill that aimed to punish and jail parents of children who missed school with little consideration of the socio-political context that truancy occurs in. (See here: www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/31/kamala-harris-laughed-jailing-parents-truancy). After the Supreme Court ruled that California reduce its overcrowded prison population that was suffering from starvation and inhumane treatment, Harris’ office argued that this would reduce the prison labour pool. Harris is on record pledging unconditional support to Israel who, empowered by the strategic and special relationship it enjoys with the United States, openly defies international law and numerous UN resolutions around human rights abuses (See here https://www.thekashmirmonitor.net/we-must-stand-with-israel-kamala-harris-is-yet-another-supporter-of-eviction-of-palestinians/ ). According to columnist Vineeta Singh “Kamala Harris’ career shows us how, if we use our privileges correctly, play by the rules, don’t scare white people by making radical claims (for example, that poor Black people matter every bit as much as any wealthy person); if we are willing to put our smiling “diverse” faces as stamps of approval on white supremacist policies, we too can be the face of white supremacist mass incarceration.”. (See Full article: https://feminisminindia.com/2020/08/24/kamala-harris-not-the-south-asian-icon-we-want/)

If the record of both Biden and Harris are anything to go on, then we can expect four years of little change to the internally and globally violent US State beyond smiling diverse faces, platitudes and inspirational meme-worthy gestures and words. Beyond the feel-goodism of the Biden and Harris leadership, there are many people within the US and globally who are negatively affected by US policies. Mass surveillance and erosion of privacy, systemic racism, police brutality, US imperialism and intervention, unbridled neoliberal capitalism and the ongoing industrial prison complex are all ongoing issues that are affecting the global village. The embeddedness of both Biden and Harris in American neoliberal capitalism that easily prioritises power and profit over people and the environment suggest that we be cautious about the hope and change that they allegedly represent. Biden and Harris offer us a very different approach to Trump, reminding us that US imperialism does not have to be white, loud, hostile and belligerent. It can be brown, soft, polite and diplomatic.

Dr Tye Salandy is a sociologist residing in Trinidad and Tobago. He can be reached at tyesalandy@gmail.com.

6 thoughts on “Biden/Harris and the Diverse Faces of US Imperialism”

  1. One step at a time Ras. So many scenarios that can playoff, if, or when this diverse bunce ever have a ‘union’ to govern.
    Check back next month for an update. They say it is, unprecedented.
    It doh take much for it to descend into chaos and anarchy…

    Breakin News: Violent clashes between supporters of President Donald Trump and counterprotesters erupted in the streets of downtown Washington, D.C., Saturday night after thousands of the president’s supporters rallied earlier in the day to protest election results they say are fraudulent.

    As a matter of Fact, Ras… Give us an update next week..

    https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/trump-supporters-protest-in-dc-crowds-gather-at-freedom-plaza/2475292/

  2. While the good doctor has correctly pointed out all of the ills and faults of governing in a large, corrupt and complicated society as the United States, he fails to mention the balancing acts people like Barack, Biden, Hillary and now Kamala have to display to make simple gains. America is a country at war with itself. The war to end slavery is still alive (though in different form) because the South is still bitter about the outcome. The “confederacy” is still alive and shows its ugly head in the south. It is common to see those rednecks in places like Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Louisiana, Alabama and Mississippi display their large flying confederate flags on their F150s. That’s commonplace and it’s a symbol of something. It’s called “resistance”. That’s what in store for Biden and Kamala. So while we in the Caribbean, Africa and India are “proud” of Kamala’s achievements, the road ahead is fraught with obstacles and uncertainties because this election was not well received by the white supremacists.

    In this complicated and sometimes hostile world where race and racial superiority is the unspoken motive, we need to cherish any gains we can get, no matter how small.

    1. Soooo Biden and Kamala aren’t also white supremacists?
      Kian, Kamala explicitly said in an interview last year when questioned on the issue of reparations for african americans, that she would NOT support anything that’s exclisively for them “Noooooo!”. She’s a typical white identified, anti-black bi-racial….Trinidad and the caribbean are rampant with her type…Indian parent and mulatto-ish parent! Kamala’s racist family strained the relationship with her parents, and the only reason her mother was able to take her to india and be accepted by the family to a degree, is because of her light skin, straight hair and racially ambiguous features. If Donald Harris was not light skinned with mulatto-ish features, Kamala’s mother would NEVER have married him and certainly not carried Kamala to india to “Show Off”! Did you know that Kamala’s mother’s documents in america revealed that she ticked off WHITE as her race? (Most indians even from the caribbean do this). Kamala harris’s father dated down to Kamala’s mother in terms of looks, because Jamaica, just like trinidad, has a racist social hierarchy that places indians, mulattos and all non phenotypically pure blooded africans ABOVE BLACK AFRICANS and her father’s family and peers, more than likely patted him on the back for his “achievement”.
      As for “Jim Crow” Joe Biden, he was publicly as a senator against his children’s school being desegregated because he didn’t want them being raised in a…get this… “Racial Jungle”! Biden, just like indians in trinidad and the caribbean, have refined and toned down their racism since the 70’s for political and economic well being.
      Biden said in 1977 that desegregation would create ‘a racial jungle’ – Business Insider
      https://www.businessinsider.com/biden-said-desegregation-would-create-a-racial-jungle-2019-7

      Also Kian, Kamala will be partial to UNC over PNM just like trump and Obama. Pay close attention!

      1. Truth… I have not been following… But, how did Kamala ended up at Howard University, a historical ‘Black’ university? The founder of the PNM, Dr. Williams spent 16 years teaching there, and the President of Howard today is Afro-Trinbagonian.

        1. RamK LOL! Seriously? Howard and other HBCU’s have a documented and studied history of all manner of caribbean and other mulattos and other no-whites attending but outside of school, distancing themselves from african struggles and aiming for “whiteness”. I personally know of many trinidadians who never socialize or date/marry african people (genuinely) before and after attending Howard and other HBCU’s, and yet they use their attendence as an affirmation of their respect for africans. By the way…where did 1995-2001 UNC minister Adesh Nanan study Dentistry again?? HBCU’s like Howard, are SUPPOSED to be a metting place of substance for africans and other people who love and respect africans BUT, it also attracts people especially kamala’s generation, who just want to “dabble” in blackness when they’re young for fun!

  3. Although Americans like to boast about their democratic system of government and their “wonderful” constitution, there are many complicated traps to restrict real change and the powers of every branch of their government from the Presidency down.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.