Two Trinidad and Tobagos

By Dr Selwyn R. Cudjoe
September 11, 2019

Dr. Selwyn R. CudjoeAs Boris Johnson, UK prime minister is finding out, and Keith Rowley, T&T’s prime minister has found out, it’s easier to be on the opposition benches and spout invectives than it is to be in the driver’s seat making consequential national decisions. Boris lost pivotal votes last week in the British parliament as his Tory diehards voted against him. Even his brother—Jo Johnson—resigned from his ministerial post and his seat in Parliament. Boris is likely to have the shortest tenure as a UK prime minister.

I was reminded of this scenario when I read the missive Kamla Persad-Bissessar delivered at her Monday Night Forum. She criticized the government for charging Watson Duke with sedition and rightly compared Duke’s remarks with Fitzgerald Hinds’ previous remarks. For the record, I think that the “sedition law” is anarchic. We should get rid of it.

Hinds claims that Kamla’s comparison of his remarks with those of Duke’s is a gross misreading of what he intended. He says he was “speaking in metaphor,” could not understand how Kamla misrepresented “an ordinary, innocent, colorful, wonderful sweet metaphor” (Express, August 4), and called on a professor of English at UWI to adjudicate his excellent use of that figure of speech.

As a professor who taught literature and literary theory at Harvard, Cornell and Ohio universities, I am willing to argue that Duke’s and Hinds’ remarks can be placed in the same category: “Kill them dead!” “Drive a PNM balisier deep into the hearts of the wicked UNC vampires,” “take a stake with a balisier on top and drive it deep within their heart and finish them off once and for all” have the same effect as Duke saying “the day will come for us in WASA, [when] we are prepared to die and the morgue will be picking up people.” Given the loose manner in which Duke and Hinds use language, their remarks can be read as harmless comparisons and outlandish braggadocio.

While Kamla is prepared to excoriate the government’s shortcomings (she says her duty is “to hold the Government accountable”) I wonder if she is willing to tell the national community, in concrete terms, what the UNC is willing to do about the disturbing disparities that exist in our society with regard to black young people.

I refer to a photograph of the participants of the Three-Tier Mentorship Program for Energy Professionals that was taken at its first launch at the Hyatt Regency on August 8, 2019. Five of the twenty-nine professionals were black; the rest were non-black (Ministry of Energy and Energy Industries, Facebook Page, August 15.)

There they stood with the PM, Franklyn Khan, Energy Minister, and Nicolle Olivierre, Parliamentary Secretary, and I wondered: “Did any of the officials see anything wrong with this picture,” especially as the PM proclaimed that “a cadre of energy-sector professionals is to built in T&T, the objective of which is to build capacity in the energy sector in key technical areas” (Newsday, August 8.)

My fight here is not with a Government that does not think this discrepancy matters even if young black professionals are overlooked in the process. One government minister saw “nothing wrong with this photo.” As far the government is concerned, we can file that photograph “Not Important” and carry on with other important matters.

I am interested to hear Kamla’s response to this anomaly: five young professionals in a cadre of 29 professionals in whose hands the future of the energy industry is placed. I don’t know what criteria were used for selecting these young professionals, the members of the selection committee, and the composition of future cadres of professionals but it would be nice to know.

Duke’s freedom of speech is important and must be protected but what about the necessity, perhaps the inherent fairness of future mentees in these programs, to reflect the ethnic diversity of the society and to insure we do not create two Trinidad and Tobagos: one black, unskilled and poor; the other, non-black, prosperous and privileged.

In her speech, Kamla differentiated between “covert” and “overt” discrimination. She described the latter as a situation in which “one finds a deliberate policy of denial, omission, and obfuscation of issues/persons/and groups.” She says, “persons in the haves or elite, use their influence…to prevent conversations” about those groups who “benefit economically at the expense of the society at large.”

I do not mean to criticize Kamla’s formulations of the problems she outlines but while the argument against archaic laws (the past) is important it would be nice if she examined present discriminatory practices, inherent in what she terms “covert racism,” which is dividing our society into two. Such divisions could have devastating consequences for the future of our society.

It is one thing to call oneself, “Trini to the bone,” and to label the present government Rowley’s “tyrant’s society,” it’s quite another thing to create a society in which covert discrimination does not show up in the tiny nooks and crannies of the society. As a leader who is committed to the elimination of covert discrimination, it would be nice to hear Kamla’s response, in concrete terms, to this nagging problem that is endemic to our society.

I don’t know if the photograph of the Three-Tier Mentorship Program can be described as a metaphor of the discriminatory nature of our society but I am inclined to believe that it fits beautifully into the adage: “a picture is worth a thousand words.”

Mr. Hinds and his government may not want to see this photo as a metonymy but it hurts nonetheless to see it.

3 thoughts on “Two Trinidad and Tobagos”

  1. Not sure about the purpose of this article. The PNM pull out an old colonial law long disband in our mother country England who actually wrote the law. It was meant back in the day to suppress free thought and any form of rebellion.

    A shrewd Rowley understand like all African Chiefs the best enemy is a dead one or in this case one who is in jail. He summoned his most loyal lackey Al Rawi to find or invent a law that subjugates anyone who dares to oppose his government.

    The sedition laws must be change or altered to foster the public good or harmony. Duke is a lose cannon so to Roget who fired their cannons at Kamla threatening destruction. One of them walked around with a mannequin and sexual abuse the dead piece of plastic. Kamla took it all in strides and now standing up to defend Duke. Take the time to read it, if you are a journalist or someone in the public forum.

  2. I am speculating that it would be impossible to increase the number of Afro-Trini Energy Professionals in the mentorship programme if the vast majority of these energy professionals are non- African.
    I suspect that it would be impossible to find Africans in a field where there are so few?
    There is something wrong with the picture if young Black professionals were overlooked.
    I believe that an explanation from the Ministry is needed to clarify.

  3. If in fact there were very few Afro-Trinbagonians to select from, whose fault is that?
    This picture which is “worth a thousand words” has caused pain for Dr. Cudjoe.
    Now that the shoe is on the other foot, maybe many would understand how the largest minority population in T&T have felt for decades as they were underrepresented in almost every institution, social,cultural and political.

Comments are closed.